Jump to content

Photo

Banned List Prediction: September 2013


  • This topic is locked This topic is locked
28 replies to this topic

#1
TheCardWarrior

TheCardWarrior

    Junior Member

  • Junior Member
  • 10 posts
    • Time Online: 22h 31m 22s
  • Team:Babylon Rising
  • Country: Country Flag
Hi there. We've seen what the meta's done insofar. I'm here to say what needs to get hit so hard it doesn't know what happened. Let's observe.
To save space, I will only put new cards to the list. I'll provide reasons for each card here.
~banned~
BLS - Envoy of the Beginning
-fankly a total gamebreak. Especially if rumors are true and it gets reprinted in new tins
Ally of Justice Catastor
-see above
Infestation Pandemic
-makes broken stall card immune to spell/traps? Let's just scoop now, shall we?
Spellbook of Judgment
-"A +9 and a monster? Why not?" says Konami.
~Limited~
Mecha Phantom Beast Dracossack
-an invicible boss for a tier 1 deck that can blow crap up. Seems self-explanitory to me.
Sangan
-Wind-Ups and Chaos Drags are already dead. Why should he stay banned?
Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier
-why not? It's slow for current meta, nothing would change.
Gungnir, Dragon of the Ice Barrier
-......it blows stuff up(and with merlantean, it's not only free, you're being paid to)
Grapha, Dragon Lord of Dark World
-gamebreak, gamebreak, and a little more gamebreak
Atlantean Dragoons
-"Let's make a searcher that can't be stopped because it activate in the grave by dumping with whatever you want!"........
Spellbook of Eternity
-Come on, people, it's a +2....
Spellbook of Secrets/Spellbook Magician of Prophecy
-lets them search for more searchers to wreck the game....yay...
Blaster/Tidal/Redox/Tempest
-Redox is Monster Reborn, Tidal is Foolish Burial, Blaster pops anything, Tempest searches. All basically free.
Evilswarm Ophion
-Stupidly OP. Has massive attack that's already hard to get around. And that's completly ignoring that you can't summon level 5's anyway...
Galaxy Queen's Light
-because, you know, high-ranked xyz monsters are so fair....
~Semi-Limited-
Deck Lockdown
-shuts down basically all meta easily
Wind-Up Magician
-who cares about Wind-Ups anymore?
Starlight Road
-......
Number 11: Big Eye
-I really don't think he actually needs to get hit that hard, being as most(if not all) tier 1 decks run him. Since he can take another copy, who cares?
~off list~
Summoner Monk
-because meta uses him...
Thunder King Rai-Oh
-why's he semi-limited, exactly?
Card Trooper
-no one runs this
Magical Stone Excavation
-see above
T.G. Striker
-Was there a real reason he was on the list? No? I didn't think so.

I wonder how this will work. TCG and OCG banlists totally different.

BANNED STRATOS AND JUDGMENT!

 

~OPINION~

STRATOS TO 3, OPHION TO 0, ROOSTER TO 0, FROG THE JAM TO 0, POT OF AVARICE TO 3, CARD DESTRUCTION TO 3, RESCUE RABBIT TO 3, TKING TO 0, POT OF BENEVOLENCE TO 0, POT OF GREED TO 4!!!

Jk, can you imagine how much it'd suck to not have Frog the Jam?

 


#2
kpnut

kpnut

    the Cry of the Wind

  • Veteran Members
  • 2,665 posts
    • Time Online: 282d 6h 21m 13s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Sunny Scotland

first off too early, secondly read the rules of the section: http://forum.dueling...-limited-rules/



#3
Zeh

Zeh

    Instrumentum Mortis

  • War Adjudicator
  • 2,334 posts
    • Time Online: 248d 4h 43m
  • Team:AE
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Blacksburg, Virginia

~banned~
Ally of Justice Catastor
-see above

Even if this thread wasn't against the rules:  No, just no.


[3:16:23 AM] F. Barkles the Magnificent: your first mistake was thinking

Zhadow: i love how zeh is like "sure, gonna brutalize your wishes and dreams either way"

[8:00:23 PM] Mario: id be really embarassed right now
[8:00:25 PM] Mario: if i knew what shame was


#4
Alexanderization

Alexanderization

    Light Your Heart Up

  • Veteran Members
  • 727 posts
    • Time Online: 134d 11h 41m 56s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Lurker's Paradise.

Hi there. We've seen what the meta's done insofar. I'm here to say what needs to get hit so hard it doesn't know what happened. Let's observe.
To save space, I will only put new cards to the list. I'll provide reasons for each card here.
Spellbook of Judgment
Spellbook of Eternity
Spellbook of Secrets/Spellbook Magician of Prophecy
 

 

The disdain for Prophecy is real in this list. 

 

And you have some questionable predictions too, like Catastor or Galaxy Queen's Light.


OgeW7W2.png


#5
HikariOblivion

HikariOblivion

    Archfiend Commander

  • Veteran Members
  • 1,770 posts
    • Time Online: 231d 2h 2m 3s
  • Team:Team Elemental Mistress (TEM)

Hi there. We've seen what the meta's done insofar. I'm here to say what needs to get hit so hard it doesn't know what happened. Let's observe.
To save space, I will only put new cards to the list. I'll provide reasons for each card here.
~banned~
BLS - Envoy of the Beginning
-fankly a total gamebreak. Especially if rumors are true and it gets reprinted in new tins

BLS's power dwindles as time goes by. I believe the word for him now is "glass cannon"
Ally of Justice Catastor
-see above

Newp. Catastor is fair. 

Infestation Pandemic
-makes broken stall card immune to spell/traps? Let's just scoop now, shall we?

Nah. A limit I could see, but it's not banworthy. Powerful, but not banworthy. 

Spellbook of Judgment
-"A +9 and a monster? Why not?" says Konami.

Breaks the game, yes. 
~Limited~
Mecha Phantom Beast Dracossack
-an invicible boss for a tier 1 deck that can blow crap up. Seems self-explanitory to me.

Hit the catalyst before hitting the elixir. 
Sangan
-Wind-Ups and Chaos Drags are already dead. Why should he stay banned?

TGU makes it ridiculous
Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier
-why not? It's slow for current meta, nothing would change.

PAH!
Gungnir, Dragon of the Ice Barrier
-......it blows stuff up(and with merlantean, it's not only free, you're being paid to)

Once again, hit the catalyst before hitting the elixir. 

Grapha, Dragon Lord of Dark World
-gamebreak, gamebreak, and a little more gamebreak

Meh. I'd rather see the deck live, than be completely killed off. If you want to hit Dark World, hit Dealings or Snoww. 
Atlantean Dragoons
-"Let's make a searcher that can't be stopped because it activate in the grave by dumping with whatever you want!"........

Hit the catalyst before hitting the elixir. This is the right case. 
Spellbook of Eternity
-Come on, people, it's a +2....
Spellbook of Secrets/Spellbook Magician of Prophecy
-lets them search for more searchers to wreck the game....yay...

Judgment gone is enough
Blaster/Tidal/Redox/Tempest
-Redox is Monster Reborn, Tidal is Foolish Burial, Blaster pops anything, Tempest searches. All basically free.

Yes.
Evilswarm Ophion
-Stupidly OP. Has massive attack that's already hard to get around. And that's completly ignoring that you can't summon level 5's anyway...

If you hit something, hit Pandemic. Wait, you're already doing that. Okay then, Ophion to 3. 
Galaxy Queen's Light
-because, you know, high-ranked xyz monsters are so fair....

-1 combo card to perform a -1 or -2 summon. 
~Semi-Limited-
Deck Lockdown
-shuts down basically all meta easily

Perfectly fine at 3. 
Wind-Up Magician
-who cares about Wind-Ups anymore?

Seriously. Did you ever even encounter the Shock lock? 

Starlight Road
-......

OH NO PROTECTION. Also it's only run at 1, maybe 2 anyway. 

Number 11: Big Eye
-I really don't think he actually needs to get hit that hard, being as most(if not all) tier 1 decks run him. Since he can take another copy, who cares?

Catalyst before Elixir. That said, yes he's pretty damn broke if level 7s are spammable. Let's take the level 7s down a notch and see what happens. 
~off list~
Summoner Monk
-because meta uses him...

Sure
Thunder King Rai-Oh
-why's he semi-limited, exactly?

Fine by me
Card Trooper
-no one runs this

Troop Dupe Scoop? Mh. Dunno. 

Magical Stone Excavation
-see above

Has it's uses, but nobody uses more than 2 anyway. 
T.G. Striker
-Was there a real reason he was on the list? No? I didn't think so.

Naturia trauma.


Edited by HikariOblivion, 09 June 2013 - 06:46 PM.

I color the world in the hues of my madness.MalkavArchfiend.png


#6
LordTyranus

LordTyranus

    Elite Member

  • Banned
  • 2,377 posts
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Still trying in vain to find out.

What are you smoking, BLS banned right after they make reprints and CATASTOR? WTF ARE YOU SMOKING



first off too early, secondly read the rules of the section: http://forum.dueling...-limited-rules/

early, wrong, and frankly really bad predictions I would quit if Konomi did this


 


#7
! Juha Bach !

! Juha Bach !

    Veteran Member

  • Member
  • 341 posts
    • Time Online: 5d 10h 13m 8s
  • Country: Country Flag

The suggestions are hilarious. 

 

lololololololololoolololol


Edited by ! Juha Bach !, 09 June 2013 - 08:15 PM.


#8
*Painless*

*Painless*

    Siding Magician of Prophecy

  • Member
  • 603 posts
    • Time Online: 12d 17h 46m 3s
  • Team:Volt Switch
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Virginia

Are these just some cards you don't like?


<inserts random signature>

 

burns kinda exspensive.  id try a dark magician deck. 

 

 


#9
AshBunLuv

AshBunLuv

    Elite Member

  • Member
  • 3,093 posts
    • Time Online: 169d 15h 1m 32s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Somewhere over the rainbow.

That made me lol. Your predicitions are bad:/


AshDraft2_zps6b17a08f.png

VsWxgo2.png


#10
RareHunter

RareHunter

    Inzektor Veteran

  • Veteran Members
  • 7,666 posts
    • Time Online: 127d 8h 1m 15s
  • Facebook:http://www.facebook.com/adi.goofy
  • Twitter:@adigoofy
  • Country: Country Flag

anyone can gimme a pic about ***** form? this dude really need it

 

That made me lol. Your predicitions are bad:/

it still better than what Patrick Hobban did when March 2012 Ban List prediction..


Edited by RareHunter, 09 June 2013 - 10:15 PM.

Stop asking Inzektor's Ruling, click banner below to find your answer


9Foab.jpg


MY DECK LIST

298531.jpg


#11
Dush

Dush

    Member

  • Member
  • 154 posts
    • Time Online: 5d 1h 14m 23s
  • Location:The Land of Albion...

Stopped reading to go cut my wrist once it say Catastor... then I came back and kept reading... And I saw Trishula and cut my other wrist. There is no logic behind anything on this list- and it is by far the WORST list I've EVER seen....

 

Is this a joke?



#12
gelaion

gelaion

    Elite Member

  • Veteran Members
  • 2,890 posts
    • Time Online: 147d 11h 28m 53s
  • Team:[FOG] Owner/Captain/Founder
  • Location:L.A
It is not dnf ban listt madness season yet please dontt start it early

gelaionname.png

 

teJosK0.jpg

 


#13
Demonic Psycho

Demonic Psycho

    The Demon of Chaos

  • Veteran Members
  • 549 posts
    • Time Online: 29d 42m 37s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:The Dark Abyss

Yea, hit Ophion and Pandemic when all the big stuff is Monster Effects... This list is full of fail...

 

/Thread



#14
LordTyranus

LordTyranus

    Elite Member

  • Banned
  • 2,377 posts
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Still trying in vain to find out.

this guy is nuts, don't honor him by reading this post anymore


 


#15
EW Scarlet

EW Scarlet

    「Musical ☆ Princess」

  • Veteran Members
  • 569 posts
    • Time Online: 95d 14h 45m 52s
  • Team:[Akai] Akai Tsuki
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:The Grand Spellbook Tower

Unbanning Trishula is possibly one of the worst ideas Konami could have. You also hit all the wrong cards. Galaxy Queen's Light is not seeing any level of even casual play, let alone competitive. You won't see it on a top 8 table at your average sized local, let alone the top 8 tables at a actual event. Spellbook of Eternity is not a +2. It replaces itself with another Spellbook. That makes it a break even. Dark Worlds are not doing anything. You even hit the deck wrong. Instead of crippling it entirely, hit Dragged Down and Card Destruction. Those two are the major problem cards. You can argue Snoww too, so that would be 3rd on your list. The point of a banlist is to weaken decks, not destroy them. Only in really extreme cases should you be forced to flat out destroy a deck from existence. Sangan should stay banned on emphasis of design, and how overly versitile the card actually is. Overall this list is cluttered with personal bias hits, Catastor, Gungnir and personal bias unhits, Trishula, Sangan and so on. That's not how to make a banlist. You need to be unbiased in your opinion. You can't let a deck off if you like it. That's just not how banlists work.
 


Edited by EW Scarlet, 09 June 2013 - 10:52 PM.

ZiOWhWw.png

Thanks danna~


#16
Demonic Psycho

Demonic Psycho

    The Demon of Chaos

  • Veteran Members
  • 549 posts
    • Time Online: 29d 42m 37s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:The Dark Abyss

anyone can gimme a pic about ***** form? this dude really need it

 

it still better than what Patrick Hobban did when March 2012 Ban List prediction..

4291833398_f05abd2e24_z.jpg?zz=1

 

 

 

Here ya go dude


Edited by Demonic Psycho, 09 June 2013 - 10:52 PM.


#17
LordTyranus

LordTyranus

    Elite Member

  • Banned
  • 2,377 posts
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Still trying in vain to find out.

Unbanning Trishula is possibly one of the worst ideas Konami could have. You also hit all the wrong cards. Galaxy Queen's Light is not seeing any level of even casual play, let alone competitive. You won't see it on a top 8 table at your average sized local, let alone the top 8 tables at a actual event. Spellbook of Eternity is not a +2. It replaces itself with another Spellbook. That makes it a break even. Dark Worlds are not doing anything. You even hit the deck wrong. Instead of crippling it entirely, hit Dragged Down and Card Destruction. Those two are the major problem cards. You can argue Snoww too, so that would be 3rd on your list. The point of a banlist is to weaken decks, not destroy them. Only in really extreme cases should you be forced to flat out destroy a deck from existence. Sangan should stay banned on emphasis of design, and how overly versitile the card actually is. Overall this list is cluttered with personal bias hits, Catastor, Gungnir and personal bias unhits, Trishula, Sangan and so on. That's not how to make a banlist. You need to be unbiased in your opinion. You can't let a deck off if you like it. That's just not how banlists work.
 

I have a bad/good feeling that trish will be back in spetmeber


 


#18
Demonic Psycho

Demonic Psycho

    The Demon of Chaos

  • Veteran Members
  • 549 posts
    • Time Online: 29d 42m 37s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:The Dark Abyss

I have a bad/good feeling that trish will be back in spetmeber

Because Level 9 Synchros aren't seeing play? Don't kid yourself, as soon as Trish comes back, they will!

 

Well, Trish anyway... Hopefully Konami realizes this and keeps her banished in the Shadow Realm for eternity...



#19
*Painless*

*Painless*

    Siding Magician of Prophecy

  • Member
  • 603 posts
    • Time Online: 12d 17h 46m 3s
  • Team:Volt Switch
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Virginia

I have a bad/good feeling that trish will be back in spetmeber

I mean why not? Maybe Maybe. xD Just dont be too sure.


<inserts random signature>

 

burns kinda exspensive.  id try a dark magician deck. 

 

 


#20
SNSDfanboy.7-21

SNSDfanboy.7-21

    Junior Member

  • Junior Member
  • 34 posts
    • Time Online: 2d 15h 25m 15s

Because BLS Envoy of the Beginning is used in all the Meta decks? Yes let's ban a card that sees no play in the meta because that will totally solve the problems of the format...



#21
The Vampire Prince

The Vampire Prince

    I can take the sky from you

  • Trade Boss
  • 2,337 posts
    • Time Online: 215d 17h 15m 31s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Dark Side of The Moon


Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image


Forum Moderator - Chat Moderator - Trade Boss


Posted Image


#22
MrMcThrasher

MrMcThrasher

    Reign In Blood

  • Veteran Members
  • 3,922 posts
    • Time Online: 61d 22h 42m 22s
  • Team:[BOB] Band Of Brothers
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:California

anyone can gimme a pic about ***** form? this dude really need it

 

it still better than what Patrick Hobban did when March 2012 Ban List prediction..

What was that like?  I don't remember.


f3aHfUG.gif


#23
LordTyranus

LordTyranus

    Elite Member

  • Banned
  • 2,377 posts
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Still trying in vain to find out.

 

Because BLS Envoy of the Beginning is used in all the Meta decks? Yes let's ban a card that sees no play in the meta because that will totally solve the problems of the format...

 

why even bother comment to him its a bad ban list surprised he did'nt say fufu +dim fu back



What was that like?  I don't remember.

Bad, really bad, something about wind ups if im not mistaken


 


#24
PsyBomb

PsyBomb

    Veteran Member

  • Veteran Members
  • 530 posts
    • Time Online: 28d 9h 1m 43s
  • Country: Country Flag
Notice how that's his only post ever on DN? Someone lock this troll thread, please

#25
Masteryder

Masteryder

    Veteran Member

  • Veteran Members
  • 615 posts
    • Time Online: 32d 2h 27m 43s
  • Facebook:masteryder
  • Twitter:masteryder
  • Youtube:mrmasteryder
  • Team:Stardust Academy
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Murten (Fribourg)

I stopped reading here :

"

~banned~

Ally of Justice Catastor

"


neucdu.jpg

tumblr_mqgdla21Xw1squmrro1_400.gif





0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

Welcome to the Dueling Network Forums!

To sign in, use your duelingnetwork.com account. If you do not have one, register here.