Jump to content

Photo

Crimson Blader vs Colossal Fighter


Best Answer  Key, 23 June 2013 - 02:48 AM

Since they both trigger at the same time.  It would be a SEGOC. 

 

So.

  1. Turn Player's Mandatory Effects
  2. Non-Turn Player's Mandatory Effects (Crimson Blader)
  3. Turn Player's Optional Effects (Colossal Fighter)
  4. Non-Turn Player's Optional Effects 

Crimson CL1, Colossal CL2

Crimson Blader, like Shura, needs to stay face-up for its effect to activate.

Go to the full post »


  • This topic is locked This topic is locked
16 replies to this topic

#1
Solemn Brigade

Solemn Brigade

    Junior Member

  • Junior Member
  • 61 posts
    • Time Online: 5d 17h 40m 27s
  • Location:California

I read both the cards and realized they both trigger when sent to grave.

 

Since Colossal Fighter is optional could you put it as chain link 2 and use Colossal Fighter's effect to reborn Crimson Blader?



#2
Ragonai Izoku

Ragonai Izoku

    Dress Break!

  • Member
  • 488 posts
    • Time Online: 33d 16h 24m 47s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Oharu-chan's Tea Shop

I believe you can.


20804.jpg


#3
(ReactionGod) Zane

(ReactionGod) Zane

    F.Barkles the Magnificent's Son

  • Veteran Members
  • 655 posts
    • Time Online: 74d 21h 1m 22s
  • Team:I'm Out ~
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Killuminati sign ups

Yes you can, same reason you can reborn the same Colossal Fighter that was just destroyed


Edited by (ReactionGod) Zane, 23 June 2013 - 02:26 AM.

tumblr_lwxutcUTMB1qmc6jxo1_400.gif

Zeh: FITE ME IRL

Future War Adjudicator| Wanna-be In-Game Administrator | Hopeless Tournament Organizer

 

 


#4
.Noisia

.Noisia

    Member

  • Member
  • 176 posts
    • Time Online: 13d 9h 11m 2s
  • Country: Country Flag

Yep, you can do that.


#gone.


#5
Argor42

Argor42

    Let Justice Be Done, Though the Heavens Fall

  • War Adjudicator
  • 1,836 posts
    • Time Online: 159d 18h 4m 8s
  • Team:[SABY] Shadows of the Abyss
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Places

Why would Colossal Fighter be on CL 2 if it suicides into Blader? Blader doesn't activate in that case.


Senior Administrator | Tournament Organizer | War Adjudicator

argorsig_by_releane028-d7mt8cp.png

72MnO1z.png
Credit to Releane for these sigs




 

argor42_userbar_by_zoisitesarugaki-d7i91
something_looks_yummy__userbar_by_zoisit
Credit to Zoisite for these userbars


#6
Solemn Brigade

Solemn Brigade

    Junior Member

  • Junior Member
  • 61 posts
    • Time Online: 5d 17h 40m 27s
  • Location:California

Why would Colossal Fighter be on CL 2 if it suicides into Blader? Blader doesn't activate in that case.

 

Since they both trigger at the same time.  It would be a SEGOC. 

 

So.

  1. Turn Player's Mandatory Effects
  2. Non-Turn Player's Mandatory Effects (Crimson Blader)
  3. Turn Player's Optional Effects (Colossal Fighter)
  4. Non-Turn Player's Optional Effects 

Crimson CL1, Colossal CL2



#7
HyperJYGBSP

HyperJYGBSP

    The Galaxy's Honourable Infinity Blaze Galaxy Wizard Marshal

  • Member
  • 3,054 posts
    • Time Online: 120d 10h 6m 12s
  • Facebook:Hyper Cute
  • Twitter:Hyper Adorable
  • Youtube:HyperJYGBSP
  • Team:[DLLR] Team D.O.L.L.A.R.S's Quad Wielding Yoshi (Heh)(And NEVER CALL ME HYPER)
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Singapore - Twilight Of The Gods(Kamigami)[UTC + 8]

Crimson Blader says

"If this card destroys a monster by battle and sends it to the Graveyard"
When Colossal Fighter AND Crimson Blader are destroyed by battle with each other, Crimson Blader cannot trigger as it is in the Graveyard by the time Colossal Fighter has been sent.

Crimson Blader must survive the battle to activate it's effect


Edited by HyperJYGBSP, 23 June 2013 - 02:46 AM.


#8
 Key

 Key

    ─═╬ Δ Ð ⊙ Я ﻪ ß ╚ Σ

  • Veteran Members
  • 945 posts
    • Time Online: 67d 1h 58s
  • Team:s{EX} Exiles
  • Country: Country Flag
✓  Best Answer

Since they both trigger at the same time.  It would be a SEGOC. 

 

So.

  1. Turn Player's Mandatory Effects
  2. Non-Turn Player's Mandatory Effects (Crimson Blader)
  3. Turn Player's Optional Effects (Colossal Fighter)
  4. Non-Turn Player's Optional Effects 

Crimson CL1, Colossal CL2

Crimson Blader, like Shura, needs to stay face-up for its effect to activate.


Posted Image


Posted Image


#9
Solemn Brigade

Solemn Brigade

    Junior Member

  • Junior Member
  • 61 posts
    • Time Online: 5d 17h 40m 27s
  • Location:California

Crimson Blader says

"If this card destroys a monster by battle and sends it to the Graveyard"
 

 

 

Shura says

 

"When this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle and sends it to the Graveyard, you can"



Aren't the two cases different? If denotes a mandatory effect so it would trigger regardless if it was still on field. While when you can denotes an optional effect so of course shura would have to be on field to resolve. 



#10
HyperJYGBSP

HyperJYGBSP

    The Galaxy's Honourable Infinity Blaze Galaxy Wizard Marshal

  • Member
  • 3,054 posts
    • Time Online: 120d 10h 6m 12s
  • Facebook:Hyper Cute
  • Twitter:Hyper Adorable
  • Youtube:HyperJYGBSP
  • Team:[DLLR] Team D.O.L.L.A.R.S's Quad Wielding Yoshi (Heh)(And NEVER CALL ME HYPER)
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Singapore - Twilight Of The Gods(Kamigami)[UTC + 8]

Shura says

 

"When this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle and sends it to the Graveyard, you can"



Aren't the two cases different? If denotes a mandatory effect so it would trigger regardless if it was still on field. While when you can denotes an optional effect so of course shura would have to be on field to resolve. 

Point being that Crimson Blader has already left the field, as such it would not trigger.

This has nothing to do with being Mandatory or Optional, but rather that the conditions were never there



#11
Solemn Brigade

Solemn Brigade

    Junior Member

  • Junior Member
  • 61 posts
    • Time Online: 5d 17h 40m 27s
  • Location:California

Ok that makes sense.



#12
Miror B.

Miror B.

    Master of SWOG

  • Chat Moderator
  • 9,711 posts
    • Time Online: 247d 14h 31m 19s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Under my sis's bed...waiting for you...

Aren't the two cases different? If denotes a mandatory effect so it would trigger regardless if it was still on field. While when you can denotes an optional effect so of course shura would have to be on field to resolve. 

1) "If" does not denote mandatory. "Can" denotes optional, no "can" denotes mandatory.

2) No they aren't different. If a card requires to send the monster to the graveyard by battle, it must stay on the field to see the monster go to the graveyard.


About Miror

 

 

Think about this for a bit:

'DN experience' indicates how much sensual pleasure you give to your partner. If you play with your deck well, and give the other person a good time, then everyone can get a good experience out of it.

#13
husam88

husam88

    Junior Member

  • Member
  • 41 posts
    • Time Online: 6d 1h 13m 42s
  • Country: Country Flag

Doesn't the effect of Crimson Blader activates the opponent's next turn anyways?

If I suicided my Colossal Fighter against Crimson Blader, it can be summoned via its own effect, regardless of the case. And then, if I am going to take into account the effect of Crimson Blader (even though I shouldn't, since it was not face-up on the field for its effect to activate), it will not count until my next turn.



#14
genexwrecker

genexwrecker

    Sailor Scout of ruling knowledge

  • Veteran Members
  • 8,692 posts
    • Time Online: 257d 22h 23m 33s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:IL

Doesn't the effect of Crimson Blader activates the opponent's next turn anyways?

 

._.

 

please read crimson cards do not  activate an entire turn after their trigger


 

lDfQq7q.png

Never forget Lightning Laxus! Dn Admin 2-20-14 until 7-6-14

ItyCqOB.png

genex_11.png

 http://i.imgur.com/VWFSyAI.png I own the account genexwreckersucks it is not some one bashing me its just me hating myself.

 

 


#15
husam88

husam88

    Junior Member

  • Member
  • 41 posts
    • Time Online: 6d 1h 13m 42s
  • Country: Country Flag

._.

 

please read crimson cards do not  activate an entire turn after their trigger

 

I read it, and it says, I qoute:

 

If this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle and sends it to the Graveyard: Your opponent cannot Normal or Special Summon Level 5 or higher monsters during their next turn.

 

During their next turn. Meaning, not the same turn I attacked with my Colossal (let's assume it was weakend, for the sake of the argument) their Crimson.



#16
genexwrecker

genexwrecker

    Sailor Scout of ruling knowledge

  • Veteran Members
  • 8,692 posts
    • Time Online: 257d 22h 23m 33s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:IL

I read it, and it says, I qoute:

 

If this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle and sends it to the Graveyard: Your opponent cannot Normal or Special Summon Level 5 or higher monsters during their next turn.

 

During their next turn. Meaning, not the same turn I attacked with my Colossal (let's assume it was weakend, for the sake of the argument) their Crimson.

its called a lingering effect


Edited by genexwrecker, 23 June 2013 - 09:47 AM.

 

lDfQq7q.png

Never forget Lightning Laxus! Dn Admin 2-20-14 until 7-6-14

ItyCqOB.png

genex_11.png

 http://i.imgur.com/VWFSyAI.png I own the account genexwreckersucks it is not some one bashing me its just me hating myself.

 

 


#17
Miror B.

Miror B.

    Master of SWOG

  • Chat Moderator
  • 9,711 posts
    • Time Online: 247d 14h 31m 19s
  • Country: Country Flag
  • Location:Under my sis's bed...waiting for you...

I read it, and it says, I qoute:

 

If this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle and sends it to the Graveyard: Your opponent cannot Normal or Special Summon Level 5 or higher monsters during their next turn.

 

During their next turn. Meaning, not the same turn I attacked with my Colossal (let's assume it was weakend, for the sake of the argument) their Crimson.

It activates right then and there, then the effect's condition lingers for their next turn.


About Miror

 

 

Think about this for a bit:

'DN experience' indicates how much sensual pleasure you give to your partner. If you play with your deck well, and give the other person a good time, then everyone can get a good experience out of it.




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

Welcome to the Dueling Network Forums!

To sign in, use your duelingnetwork.com account. If you do not have one, register here.